From rands sovietera work on game theory to todays current states of concern, such as north korea and iran, rand has applied. It focuses especially on the credibility problem inherent in nuclear deterrence, the way that con icts of interest play themselves out in the presence of nuclear weapons, and the dynamics of brinkmanship. Nuclear deterrence is based on a threat the threat to attack cities that promises an action that is not militarily decisive. Wirtz abstract nuclear and conventional deterrence are in fact quite different in terms of theory, practice, and impact. A critique of united states nuclear deterrence theory. Schelling formalized deterrence and the e ect of nuclear weapons in terms of game theory, a eld of economics which attempts to model strategic interactions between states in terms of mathematical models. Nuclear deterrence in the 21st century rand corporation. Nuclear deterrence theory, with its roots in the cold war era, may not account for all eventualities in security and defence in the 21st century, given the larger number of nuclear actors in a less binary geopolitical context. Llnls foremost responsibility is to ensure the performance of the nations nuclear arsenal. Deterrence theory is the idea that an inferior force, by virtue of the destructive power of the forces weapons, could deter a more powerful adversary, provided that this force could be protected against destruction by a surprise attack. Deterrence has been intensively studied and tested as to its use in terms of strategy in international relations, the maintenance of stability in international relations, the conduct of violence and warfare in both international and domestic contexts, and in political affairs. Nuclear deterrence as a complex system 1 w e came so close.
Deterrence presented by sheikh abir ahmed bir16 sec. Nuclear deterrence in the third millennium the major deterrent to war is in a mans mind. First, even a nuclear attack could not prevent the soviet army from overrunning western europe. My goal, of course, was to think systematically about. Dec 16, 2016 last month the modern war institute convened a conference with more than sixty government, academic, business, and military leaders to discuss deterrence in the 21 st century.
Once placed in an irrational situation, it is questionable as to whether a person, or on organisation could continue to act in a rational manner. Deterrence theory proponents of deterrence believe that people choose to obey or violate the law after calculating the gains and consequences of their actions. More specifically it is a strategy of putting in place incentives for other nations not to. Assessing the requirements for successful nuclear deterrence is harder than it appears. Less historical and more theoretical than freedman 1989. Nuclear deterrence viewed as terrorism is even less appealing. Deterrence theory has probably been one of the most studied theories in international relations since the cold war era until present, becoming none less.
Thomas schellings theories on strategy and war will live. The challenge of estimating the risk of failure of nuclear deterrence is formidable. The 1983 nuclear crisis lessons for deterrence theory and. Deterrence theory has always maintained that both sides must be able to launch a formidable countervalue attack even after absorbing a counterforce attack. Nuclear strategy developed as a means to create a rational framework of deterrence for the seemingly irrational nature of nuclear war.
Elevated to prominence after world war ii and the arrival of nuclear weapons, deterrence became the central recourse for sustaining international and internal security and stability among and within states in an era of serious conflict. Perspectives on nuclear deterrence in the 21st century. Deterrence theory holds that nuclear weapons are intended to deter other states from. Bush ordered the deployment of a national missile defense nmd. Gametheoretic analysis allows the author to explore some of the most complex and problematic issues in deterrence theory, including the effects of firststrike advantages, limited retaliation, and the number of nuclear. The knowledge gained through theory, simulations, and experiments is utilized by weapons experts to assess the condition of stockpile weapons and to develop and certify needed modifications with confidence in the absence of additional nuclear tests. Cold war, deterrence theory and evolution, nuclear deterrence, nuclear history. Applying advances in game theory to the study of nuclear deterrence, robert powell examines the foundations of deterrence theory.
Pdf 21st century nuclear deterrence, theory and ethics in an. The differences play out in various ways depending on whether strategies of denial, punishment, or retaliation constitute the basis of the deterrent. As nuclear deterrence theory during the cold war was predicated on the concept of mutually assured destruction mad, deterrence strategy required that effective and credible forces were maintained at every levelconventional and nuclear to be effective. Nuclear deterrence, however, was subject to at least three major problems. Nuclear deterrence theory, with its roots in the cold war era, may not account for all eventualities in the 21st century. Overall, however, it is difficult to prove the effectiveness of deterrence since only those offenders not deterred come to the notice of law enforcement.
Deterrence theorys central hypotheses are that crime can be prevented when punishment is certain, severe, and quick. The knowledge gained through theory, simulations, and experiments is utilized by weapons experts to assess the condition of stockpile. The reasons, spelled out in chapter two, are many, but the core principle is straightforward. Whether explicitly or implicitly, deterrencecentric philosophy serves as the. This book recommends a renewed intellectual effort on nuclear deterrence. Thus while the nuclear age would have required clausewitz to adapt his concept of absolute war to the realities of strategic nuclear deterrence, it would not have led him to make major. Central to all discussions was the deterrence theory laid out in thomas schellings arms and influence. In addition, three practical arguments put the efficacy of nuclear deterrence into doubt. Concept of deterrence and deterrence theory oxford research. Zagare abstract perfect deterrence theory is a general theory of interstate conflict that is applicable to a wide variety of realworld circumstances, including acute crises and both conventional and nuclear deterrence relationships. As long as nuclear weapons are around, even in small numbers, deterrence is the safest doctrine to deal with them. Deterrence has been widely used below the nuclear level but with very uneven results.
Nuclear weapons could be used to deter a wide range of actions e. There is, however, no single theory of deterrence if, by theory, one means a collection of logically connected hypotheses. Nuclear deterrence theory and nuclear deterrence myth, streaming video of a lecture by professor john vasquez, program in arms control, disarmament, and international security acdis, university of illinois, september 17, 2009. The legality of nuclear weapons for use and deterrence. The first section briefly overviews previous work on this subject. The objectives of deterring adversaries and assuring allies require visible and credible nuclear capabilities.
Nuclear deterrence theory, nuclear proliferation, and. Gametheoretic analysis allows the author to explore some of the most complex and problematic issues in deterrence theory, including the effects of firststrike advantages, limited retaliation, and the number of nuclear powers in the international system on the. The dod nuclear enterprise will benefit from the inclusion of concepts such as crossdomain deterrence and deterrence of nonstate actors. As a result of maintaining nuclear weapon stockpiles for deterrence purposes under mad, the united statesa nuclearweapon statehas had the opportunity to seriously. A cheat sheet1 1 nuclear crises and brinkmanship thomas c. Along with contributing to our understanding of crisis diplomacy, nuclear deterrence theory, and the stabilityinstability paradox, this study has relevance for several ongoing policy debates. Pdf nuclear deterrence theory download read online free. Johnson eastern oregon state college encyclopedia of applied ethics 1998 i. The myth of nuclear deterrence james martin center. Subtleties of deterrence theory play little role in times of crisis.
Theory and practice with special reference to nuclear india and pakistan theories of deterrence, which put forward propositions about the nature and mechanisms of deterrence, were mostly developed during the first cold war era 19451963 and dealt with the us soviet confrontation. Deterrence theory and practice with special reference to. Thomas schellings theories on strategy and war will live on. The soviet unions collapse decimated that militarys conventional force. If so, the main work of justifying punishment must rely on its deterrent e.
Deterrence theory was developed against the backdrop of the cold war nuclear arms race and focused on the prevention of nuclear conflict. The major deterrent in the future is going to be not only what we have, but what we do, what we are willing to do, what they think we will do. Nuclear deterrence theory, nuclear proliferation, and national missile defense robert powell on december 17, 2002, president george w. Stamina, guts, standing up for the things we say those are deterrents. Advocates of nuclear deterrence insist that we should thank it for the fact that a third world war has been avoided, even when tensions between the two superpowers the us and the ussr ran high.
Perhaps the most frightening thing about nuclear deterrence is its many paths to failure. Second, the nuclear threat was of no use in cases of civil war, insurgency, and other smallscale. At the heart of the misapprehension about attacking cities is a failure to understand the characteristics of attacks against civilians. It is difficult to argue that a threat of a nondecisive action is likely to coerce. Whether explicitly or implicitly, deterrence centric philosophy serves as the.
The range of nuclear deterrence strategies includes minimal or limited deterrence, massive retaliation with a force greater than that originally used by the aggressor, and mutual assured destruction mad. Deterrence theory refers broadly to a body of academic work that came to dominate the security studies literature in the united states and western europe shortly after world war ii. Performing organization names and addresses national war college,300 5th avenue,fort lesley j mcnair,washington,dc,203196000 8. The clearest outcome of increasingly accurate nuclear weapons and the counterforce vulnerability component of deterrence theory is to increase the likelihood of a first strike, while also increasing the danger that a potential victim, fearing such an. Nuclear deterrence delivered by rob green, disarmament and. Nuclear deterrence is a strategy of nations possessing significant nuclear arsenals for influencing the behavior of other nations, usually also possessing nuclear arsenals. Last month the modern war institute convened a conference with more than sixty government, academic, business, and military leaders to discuss deterrence in the 21 st century. So it is with great sadness that we say farewell to. Nuclear deterrence ensuring the safety, security, and effectiveness of the enduring stockpile llnls foremost responsibility is to ensure the performance of the nations nuclear arsenal. Section two lays out the logic of nuclear deterrence theory and deduces a number of testable hypotheses. Pdf deterrence is a tool to mitigate the risk of conflict. Deterrence today roles, challenges, and responses, analysis by lewis a. Unfortunately, nuclear deterrence no longer occupies the prominent intellectual place it once enjoyed.
The 1983 nuclear crisis lessons for deterrence theory. Deterrence theory and practice with special reference to nuclear india and pakistan free download as pdf file. The functions and structure of nuclear deterrence in the. The subject is no longer a staple of academic research, debate, and instruction. Concept of deterrence and deterrence theory oxford. Rational individuals may only be so when they exist in a rational context. Ohanlon, steven pifer, and kenneth m pollack monday, june 7. A deterrence theory of punishment by anthony ellis i start from the presupposition that the use of force against another is justi. The world came within a hair breadth of nuclear war. Jan 17, 2018 lets start by considering the core of deterrence theory. So it is with great sadness that we say farewell to schelling, who passed away on december. Other articles where nuclear deterrence is discussed. It also shows that rational deterrence theory, despite some.
The simplest version of the deterrence theory of punishment, that we may punish o. And a lethal one at that a test launch of a nuclear missile in north korea. The search for ways to characterize the risk of failure of nuclear deterrence must be conducted in a data environment for which there has never been a nuclear exchange. Utilitarianism moral theory in which no considerations other than the consequences of actions are relevant to the determination of the rightness or wrongness of those actions. A timely analysis of the future of deterrence as a strategic tool in light of the breakup of the soviet union and the rise of terrorism. First, closer inspection calls the fundamental soundness of nuclear deterrence theory into. Deterrence, extended deterrence, assurance, dissuasion, and defeat stem from the credibility of our nuclear capabilities in the minds of those we seek to deter, assure, or dissuade. The fundamentals of nuclear deterrence theory have changed little since the creation of nuclear weapons during the second world war.
Nuclear deterrence will in the future continue to have a stabilizing effect and. This credibility is attained through focused dayto. The 1983 nuclear crisis lessons for deterrence theory and practice dmitry dima adamsky lauder school of government, diplomacy and strategy, interdisciplinary center, herzliya, israel abstract this article distills insights for the scholarship of deterrence by examining the 1983 nuclear crisis the moment of maximum danger of the late. Mad is the concept that two nuclear armed nations will not strike each other under the understanding that nuclear war would annihilate both nations.
Proponents of missile defenses, both inside and outside the bush administration, argue that, absent nmd, the proliferation of nuclear. Nuclear deterrence is a strategy of nations possessing significant nuclear arsenals for influencing the behavior of other nations, usually also. Pdf 21st century nuclear deterrence, theory and ethics. Its whole aim should be to scare people straightthose who have engaged in crime specific deterrence and those who are thinking about committing crime general deterrence. How does nuclear deterrence differ from conventional. Deterrence is an old practice, readily defined and described, widely employed but unevenly effective and of questionable reliability. The belief in nuclear deterrence is based upon the crazy premise that nuclear war can be made less probable by deploying weapons and doctrines that make it more probable. The term nuclear revolution was coined by robert jervis 1989a, ch. This doctrine gained increased prominence as a military strategy during the cold war with regard to the use of nuclear weapons and is related to, but distinct.
Currently the field lacks a coherent theory or theories of nuclear asymmetry. Hardly any attention was paid to conventional deterrence. The quirks of nuclear deterrence the belfer center for science. Researchers at chatham house have worked with eight experts to produce this collection of essays examining four contested themes in contemporary policymaking on deterrence. Nuclear deterrence definition of nuclear deterrence by. There are reasons, however, for doubting the conventional wisdom. The way a state thinks about the nature of conflict drives the way it sees deterrence and. Deterrence theory s central hypotheses are that crime can be prevented when punishment is certain, severe, and quick. Foundation of nuclear deterrence developed in the cold war, the mutually assured destruction mad doctrine is the foundation of nuclear deterrence theory. Nuclear war the massive use of nuclear weapons for military purposes. How does nuclear deterrence differ from conventional deterrence. Indeed, i think i am the first person to ever write an article or book dealing explicitly with conventional deterrence. First, the theory commits us to accepting that in punishing one person in order to deter others we are unacceptably using him. During the cold war, deterrence often served as shorthand for nuclear deterrence with us nuclear forces playing a primary role in us deterrence strategies.
748 107 111 1301 839 1079 1126 623 737 1280 1265 881 1027 1494 1152 1505 415 88 268 1491 116 677 792 25 1427 1475 1194 1169 40 258 1459 139 1135